‘The Discovery of France’ by Graham Robb
History
Stephen
11/18/20266 min read
This book was originally published in 2007 with the subtitle ‘A Historical Geography from the Revolution to the First World War’, which sums up what it aims to accomplish very effectively, but which for some reason is absent from more recent paperback editions.
Over the past four decades, Graham Robb (a well-established British writer) has written several books on France and the French, including big, serious biographies of Balzac, Rimbaud and Hugo, a book about Paris and a wide-ranging overview covering two thousand years of French history. He started out as an Oxford researcher, but did not pursue an academic existence, instead establishing a successful career as a highly regarded author of books aimed at a general readership – so very much my kind of chap. He also writes superbly well.
In the introduction to this book he states that it is the product of ‘fourteen thousand miles in the saddle and four years in the library’ – by which he means a bicycle saddle and extensive archival research.
It is impossible for anyone who has an interest in France or indeed, social history, not to enjoy reading this. The amount of ground that Graham Robb covers, both geographically and historically, is extraordinary. The anecdotes harvested from memoirs and diaries come at you, one after another, thick and fast. Almost all are fascinating and I would defy anyone not to have their curiosity awakened while learning loads and enjoying the splendid prose style in which everything is related.
The first half of the book is devoted to describing traditional rural life in France before the full impact of nineteenth-century modernisation, emphasising how very limited most people’s horizons were. They did not travel much, were very poorly educated, lived as peasants in a subsistence-oriented economy, spoke a wide range of languages and dialects, were suspicious of outsiders from elsewhere in the country and did not display much, if any, notably French national identity. He then goes on in the second half to explore how and when this state of affairs changed as roads, canals and maps were created, the state educational system improved, and the tourist and cultural industries expanded alongside modern manufacturing.
There are some wonderful old photographs included too, my favourite being one showing a group of peasants walking around on stilts. These were primarily intended to allow passage across marshy ground in the Landes, but were also, it would seem, more generally used as a means of transportation that allowed practised users to walk at up to eight miles an hour. Worth bringing back into daily usage I would think?
There is an enjoyable interlude between parts one and two of the book that discusses the fate of the species of animals that laboured alongside people prior to mechanisation and modernisation – notably horses and dogs – and what might be called the ‘pet-ification process’ to which they were subjected as the twentieth century unfolded and they were no longer required to work for a living.
The book though does more than describe what happened. There is also a serious point of historical interpretation being made, namely the claim that the French as a whole (i.e. not bourgeois educated families and Parisians) only really started to modernise and develop a strong collective national identity well after the French Revolution of 1789, and in important respects not until the twentieth century. And while it is not explicitly stated, the implication is that this was rather later than in other comparable European countries.
This set me thinking about the UK and books I have read over the years about our industrial, economic and social development. Were things actually so very different here or anywhere? The key point surely is that these are very slow and diverse social processes that unfold in different ways and at different paces in different places.
I recall, for example, loving ‘Lark Rise to Candleford’, Flora Thompson’s semi-autobiographical account of her childhood in rural Oxfordshire in the late nineteenth century. Her account only deals with one locality, but it describes a series of social changes that are in many ways similar to those Graham Robb regales us with in his book about France. And it thus struck me that his book rather suffers from its extraordinarily ambitious scope which almost inevitably means that he ends up making generalisations about the vast complexity that was nineteenth-century French society from a relatively small sample of contemporary sources. You could take the first half of ‘Lark Rise’, with its fascinating description of traditional rural life in the 1880s, and see that as the typical state of affairs in the UK at that time. But it would be a misleading thing to do. The trouble with selecting colourful anecdotes to illustrate a general historical argument is that the more colourful they are, the more likely they are to be exceptional rather than representative.
And as I read on further I began to have another concern. A long-dormant memory hibernating somewhere in the deep recesses of my brain suddenly came to the fore. Now just wait a rootin’-tootin’ minute, I thought. Some forty years ago didn’t I write an essay about this stuff when I was at university? Was there not a big historical debate of a kind I started to weary of being required to wade into about when exactly European societies ‘modernised’ and became coherent national polities with a consciousness strong enough to spark the disaster that was early twentieth-century European history?
In particular I recalled reading chunks of a book by one Eugen Weber called ‘Peasants into Frenchmen’ which I thought was extraordinarily similar in nature and intent to that I was now reading by Graham Robb. So I checked it out and yes, my memory was not playing tricks. Weber’s book, subtitled ‘The Modernization of Rural France, 1870–1914’, did indeed cover a lot of this same ground and reached some very similar conclusions about the timing of modernisation in France and, more importantly, the mix of factors that brought it about. And that book pre-dated Robb’s by some thirty years. Weber summed up his almost identical purpose in the introduction as follows:
Looking for the answers to the questions that Varagnac had helped suggest drove me to discover a new France in the nineteenth-century countryside, a France where many did not speak French or know (let alone use) the metric system, where pistoles and ecus were better known than francs, where roads were few and markets distant, and where a subsistence economy reflected the most common prudence. This book is about how all this changed, and about how mentalities altered in the process; in a word, about how undeveloped France was integrated into the modern world and the official culture of Paris and the cities’.
Now of course, there is nothing wrong with aiming to write a more accessible book covering much the same ground as an earlier one, and doing so with literary flair. Building on the foundations of another book and introducing additional examples to help make the key underlying point is also a fine thing to do. But surely there is an obligation to acknowledge the existing scholarship properly and at least explain where your own interpretation varies? To do otherwise is more than a bit naughty, and I think Graham Robb can legitimately be accused of being rather casual in the acknowledgement department here. Weber’s book is included among the many hundreds of sources listed in his bibliography, so Robb was certainly aware of it. He really should, I feel, have been more up front about where his book is similar and different. Weber starts his book with a series of acknowledgements and some modest reflections on his own contribution. I really think Robb should have done something similar.
I then checked out some reviews published at the time ‘The Discovery of France’ first appeared and found some that were pretty excoriating, written by professional historians making similar points in respect of other books too. They were also sceptical about some of his claims, on the grounds that generalisations were being made from limited primary evidence. The most striking of these apparent ‘inaccuracies’ concerns Graham Robb’s suggestion that the French peasantry spent most of their winter days hibernating rather than working, a point he does rather hammer home in the first section of his book:
Men and women who did almost nothing for a large part of the year tend not to figure prominently in history books. Studies and museums naturally highlight enterprise and undervalue the art of remaining idle for months on end.
Yet as his critics pointed out, winter was also a time when rural people undertook all kinds of work, including spinning, weaving, repairing equipment and preparing for the coming agricultural year. The suggestion that much of the French peasantry spent months doing virtually nothing is, at the very least, a considerable exaggeration.
My ultimate verdict on this book is that it is enjoyable and worth reading, but very much less effectively referenced than it might be as regards secondary sources. In some respects it should be enjoyed more as a work of literature than one of serious history.
So I would advise you read this book, enjoy it, marvel at the extraordinary world Robb describes and admire the brilliance with which he describes it. Just, perhaps, don't assume that everything he tells you is quite as extraordinary, or as original, as on occasion he makes it sound. And may be, give Eugen Weber’s book a read too. It is equally enjoyable in its way and, I would say, more genuinely original in its conclusions. After forty years I am now very tempted to give it a fuller re-read, and this time without an essay deadline hanging over me.