“The Forgotten Book Club” by Kate Storey

Novel

Stephen

11/18/20263 min read

It was with some anticipation that Stephen sat down one miserable November afternoon on the brown leather sofa that was his customary reading perch and picked up his copy of ‘The Forgotten Book Club’ by Kate Storey.

As an erstwhile member of a number of reading groups himself, Stephen was hoping to enjoy this one very much. Would literature mirror any of his own experiences, he wondered?

It was a cold and wet day. Rain bashed against his window with plenty of vigour, but due to the cost of energy, Stephen and his wife Camilla were still defiantly refusing to switch on their central heating system. So instead he covered his knees and torso with a furry blanket and invited his two dogs to lie next to him so they could all keep one another warm.

Stephen read the first page. Then he read the second page. He was beginning to feel a little disappointed, which was a shame because he had been looking forward to reading the book. By the time he reached page three, his disappointment had grown considerably. He was not enjoying himself at all.

Before long Stephen was heartily regretting having to read this novel. Had he not felt some obligation to his colleagues in the reading group he would certainly not have persevered.

“Why don’t you just give up and pick up something else instead?” said Camilla, well aware of her husband's growing irritation.

Stephen shook his head. He did not agree with Camilla's suggestion. He understood why she had made it, but felt that abandoning the book would be the wrong thing to do. He therefore decided to continue reading it, rather than stopping.

And so he pushed on so as not to let others down, and somehow managed to stay awake, even when reading the novel sitting up in bed late at night, until finally he reached the book's deeply unsatisfying, supposedly heartwarming but oh so predictable end.

Stephen worried a great deal about what he should say about this book when his group met at Julian and Maggie's house in a few days' time. It was, in truth, the worst-written piece of fiction he had read for many a year, reminding him more than anything of an undemanding children's book in its style and turgid sentence construction.

“I really don't want to appear to be a terrible literary snob,” he thought to himself out loud one morning while walking along the seafront in the rain to meet his elderly parents in a coffee shop located in a neighbouring town. “I must try to say something positive.”

Perhaps, he wondered, was he now simply too old and set in his ways to appreciate contemporary fiction? Perhaps the fault lay with him rather than with the author. He considered this possibility carefully, but eventually decided that it was not so. The book really was just shockingly terrible.

He racked his brains and decided that he could, in honesty, remark that the idea behind Kate Storey's story was promising. It is essentially about the power of friendships that have been fostered in a reading group to help people cope as they go through various sorts of bad times. Might it also be said to do a reasonable job of provoking more understanding of mental health conditions like ADHD?

Such thoughts occupied him for several days one way or another as the date of the meeting drew closer.

“Oh dear, oh dear,” he mused as he drove towards Julian and Maggie's place. “How do I play this? Should I be honest or should I virtue-signal?”

It was only when he was backing up his hosts' narrow driveway, trying desperately hard not to scrape the side of his newish car and to park in a reasonably competent fashion, that he made his decision.

The book was, by any standards, a patronising, repetitive, ponderous pile of old rubbish, populated by one-dimensional characters and burdened with heaps of deeply tedious padding. So, so bad. It had absolutely no literary merit at all and he resented having wasted several hours of his life wading through its pages.

But he did not want to upset people who might have enjoyed it. So he decided, as he often found himself doing these days, that the best policy was probably not to say anything very much at all.