'The Silk House' by Kayte Nunn

Novel

Stephen

11/18/20264 min read

One of the pleasures of belonging to a reading group is that you occasionally find yourself reading a book that you would never otherwise have considered picking up, leading to wonderful new discoveries. On other occasions it leads to a situation where you feel obliged to press on to the end of a book that you are really not enjoying. I'm afraid that 'The Silk House', for me, fell rather firmly into the second category.

This is a novel by the Australian author Kayte Nunn, first published in 2020, which combines historical fiction, contemporary school drama of a sort, mystery, romance and, eventually, a pitiful helping of the supernatural. It is an ambitious mixture, and one that has evidently appealed to a great many readers. Indeed, the reviews collected together on the cover are positively ecstatic. Unfortunately, I found myself growing steadily less enthusiastic as the pages turned.

The novel tells two interwoven stories, separated by some 250 years, but connected by an old building in the fictional English town of Oxleigh in Wiltshire that I suspect may be vaguely based on Marlborough. At least it was in my imagination.

In the contemporary storyline, one Thea Rust, a young Australian history teacher and ace hockey coach, arrives to take up a post at Oxleigh College, a boys' boarding school which, after 150 years of educating young gentlemen, has finally decided to some admit some girls. Thea is given responsibility for the first small group of female pupils, who are accommodated in Silk House, an eighteenth-century building with a somewhat sinister history. Predictably enough, not everyone associated with the school is delighted by this innovation. There are reactionary masters, resentful boys, institutional prejudices and various obstacles for Thea and her pioneering charges to overcome. That story, toddles along nicely and kept me reasonably well-engaged.

The other historical storyline takes us back to 1768, when Silk House was the home and business premises of Patrick Hollander, a silk merchant, and his wife Caroline. Here we meet Rowan Caswell, a young servant girl who possesses considerable knowledge of medicinal plants and herbal remedies, an accomplishment that is not necessarily an advantage in an age when women with such skills might find themselves accused of witchcraft. We also encounter Mary-Louise Stephenson, an impoverished but talented woman determined to make her way as a designer of silk fabrics in an industry overwhelmingly dominated by men.

This part of the book initially absorbed me rather more, as is often the case with historical settings that I know little about. The Georgian silk trade is an interesting subject, as is the wider world of fashionable consumption, expanding commercial wealth and the extraordinary growth of Bath during the eighteenth century. Silk was a highly prized luxury commodity, and the fortunes to be made from supplying the fashionable classes were considerable.

For the first half of the book, I was reasonably happy to go along for the ride. Kayte Nunn knows exactly how to set up a story, introduce characters and encourage the reader to wonder what might happen next. The alternation between the two periods worked quite well, and the central device of focusing the tale on a building whose history gradually reveals itself is a perfectly serviceable one. I also liked the idea of exploring the difficulties faced by women in two very different periods, showing both how much had changed and how certain prejudices had survived.

Unfortunately though, the further I progressed, the less interested I became.

The trouble is partly one of length and pacing. At nearly 400 pages, the novel seemed to me to contain rather a lot of unnecessary padding at points, and there are too many episodes incorporated that contribute little beyond delaying the ultimate revelations. Too many conflicts seem to have been manufactured simply to keep things moving. Characters behave unreasonably, misunderstand one another, conceal information or become suddenly antagonistic in ways that owe rather more to the requirements of the plot than to any convincing psychology. At times I felt that I had wandered into an extended episode of 'EastEnders', albeit one with rather more elaborate curtain designs.

Nor did I find the characterisation particularly satisfying. The good characters are generally very good, the unpleasant ones are obligingly unpleasant, and there is not a great deal of moral ambiguity to complicate matters. Thea is resourceful and enlightened, Rowan is sympathetic and vulnerable and Mary-Louise is admirably determined to overcome the restrictions placed upon her. There is a nasty entrepreneur, a jealous PE teacher and various eccentrics who are colourfully drawn. It is all very serviceable, but clunky and predictable.

If I am honest, I also struggled increasingly with the prose. Kayte Nunn writes clearly and accessibly, and I can understand why her style appeals to readers looking for an undemanding and entertaining story. But I found it rather too simple and explicit for my taste. Emotions are explained rather than left for us to infer. Characters' motivations are repeatedly signposted and little is entrusted to the reader's imagination. There is an absence of subtlety, the writing being only a small step removed from that of a novel intended for older children.

On the cover of the book, the following slogan / subheading is included beneath the title - 'weaving, healing, haunting' - so I am not giving anything away when I say that this book, as it proceeds, becomes increasingly focused on ghosts and weird happenings in the contemporary Silk House that relate to the earlier story.

At this stage my patience ran out and I found myself yelling out 'oh for God's sake!', and worse I fear as two entirely plausible and vaguely appealing narratives were mushed together in a wholly implausible and frankly absurd manner. We even get an exorcism at one point, as the book turns into a full blown and very silly melodrama.

By the time we reached the final revelations, my patience was wearing very thin indeed. There is a concluding twist which is presumably intended to make the reader gasp in astonishment at the ingenuity of it all. My own reaction was closer to an exasperated sigh.

Oh so disappointing. I was absolutely delighted finally to have got to the end of this turgid nonsense and to be able to pick up something credible and meatier instead.