“Twilight of the Dons” by Colin Kidd

History

Stephen

11/18/20263 min read

This book is subtitled ‘British intellectuals from World War II to Thatcherism’, a subject to which it is impossible to do full justice in 220 pages. And to be fair to Colin Kidd (Professor of History at St Andrews University and a Fellow of All Souls, Oxford), he does not attempt a full survey here. His focus is on Oxford and Cambridge, particularly in the 1950s, 1960s and 1970s, and on how the public role of dons flowered and then rather wilted during this time. The story is told via a series of essays that are chronologically arranged, with a bias towards the experiences of historians and social scientists. This will, of course, naturally be of no interest whatsoever to most people, but for me it was completely fascinating. In some significant ways it builds on the analysis in one of my all-time favourite books, Noel Annan's 'Our Age', that was published back in 1990.

Some chapters are very much overviews, with lists of names featuring alongside brief commentaries about the respective individual contributions people made to academic and wider public life. These demonstrate the wide range of activity that the dons engaged in having returned to academic life with years of practical war service behind them, but do not teach the reader so much beyond making that argument.

Then, just occasionally, Professor Kidd pauses for a few pages to focus in at greater length on the life of an individual. This is something that particularly appeals to me given my fascination with the lives of leading intellectuals, not simply by their scholarly achievements, but by their backgrounds, personalities, friendships and experiences beyond the university.

Some of these people have had full biographies written about them (eg Hugh Trevor-Roper, Isaiah Berlin, Maurice Bowra, Raymond Carr etc.). Others I was broadly familiar with but interested to know much more about, particularly their war service (Robert Blake, Noel Annan, Richard Cobb, Jack Plumb). All four await a full biography, I believe, and deserve one. Then there were individuals discussed here who, perhaps very much to my discredit, I had never heard of, but whose contributions were really impressive.

Chief among them is Peter Laslett (1915–2001) of Trinity College, Cambridge, who was in the Royal Navy during World War II, then learned Japanese (as you do) and was sent to Bletchley Park to decode messages. He went on to become a respected history tutor and reader (though never sadly a professor) who wrote on both social and political subjects, bringing Annales-school thinking to his work on the UK. Meanwhile, he became a major force in the establishment first of the Open University, and then the University of the Third Age.

Then there was Bryan Wilson, who was born in 1926 into a working-class family in Leeds who lived in a tiny house with a shared outside toilet. He left school at 13, carried out a series of menial jobs and then saw his life transformed thanks to military service. After being demobbed in 1948, he spent his gratuity on a course of education, got himself a lectureship at Leeds University and wound up as a very traditionalist establishment figure at All Souls, Oxford, making (en route) a major contribution to the study of religious practice.

The book contains essays on the initial hostility of the Oxbridge establishment to the subject of sociology (for reasons I still really cannot fathom) and its simultaneous welcome for anthropology. There is a section all about contributions made to conspiracy thinking in respect of Jack Kennedy’s assassination and another focused on relationships with French scholars during the 1960s and 70s as structuralism and post-structuralism arrived to challenge traditional ways of thinking. There is a chapter on student revolts in the late 60s and another on the Thatcher government's determination to widen access to higher education and cut its cost to the public purse, while ‘scaling back’ the privileges of Oxford and Cambridge.

One reservation I have concerns the book's title - 'the twilight of the dons' - as I am not altogether convinced that their influence ever really did decline nearly as much as he suggests. Sure, we no longer have a Cabinets containing six or seven former Oxford dons, as we did in 1964, but nor should we. It is no longer possible to talk or write of a ‘Donnish Dominion’ as A. H. Halsey did in another book in this same field in a book written in the 1990s.

But academics remain prominent in public debate, while the upper reaches of the British establishment continue to be very disproportionately populated by people educated at Oxford and Cambridge. Perhaps what has changed is not so much the influence of the dons as the manner in which that influence is exercised.

All in all, a fascinating read. I took several pages of notes and learned heaps of new things.